Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Luigi Alighieri's avatar

Hi Diana,

I’ve tested your prompt on several AI models and wanted to share some feedback, hoping it might be useful to you.

First, it’s worth noting that the prompt isn’t really usable with free accounts. After about a dozen questions, the AI runs out of the context window for that conversation. I tried it with ChatGPT, Grok, and Manus, but couldn’t complete the interview in any of them.

With Gemini Pro, I had to clear its entire memory of previous chats — and even then, I’m not entirely sure I succeeded.

Without clearing the memory, it kept comparing everything I wrote to the information it had stored from hundreds of earlier conversations. As a result, it flagged numerous contradictions that had nothing to do with the profile we were trying to build.

Once I cleared its memory, the results improved, but the final profile it generated was still very generic. It seemed to rely mostly on the sample texts I was asked to provide during the interview.

Here’s an example: these are the instructions it came up with to define the AI’s triggers:

--------------------------------------------------

4. Examples of 'Triggers' for the AI

If I ask you to sell a service: Don’t talk about discounts; talk about how long it takes for people to forget about you and start being themselves.

If I ask you to describe a session: Focus on the sound of the camera and the texture of the fabrics.

-------------------------------------------------

The result is that now the AI is obsessed with the “sound of the camera” and the “texture of the clothes,” and includes them in almost every text it generates.

I've noticed, however, that Claude doesn't need this .md file because it already knows my writing style, having learned it from dozens of previous conversations.

Joseph Botelho's avatar

Writers don’t lose their voice because of AI; they lose it because they never defined it in the first place. A system only amplifies what’s already there. If the inputs are vague, the output is slop.

The real leverage isn’t a clever prompt. It’s knowing your patterns well enough to teach them.

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?